A Comparative Analysis: In-House vs Managed Document Review

Document review is a critical process in the legal industry, especially during litigation, investigations, or regulatory compliance matters. It involves the review of large volumes of documents to identify relevant information, assess their significance, and determine their potential impact on the case or matter at hand. When it comes to conducting document reviews, two main approaches are often considered: in-house document review and managed document review. Let’s compare the two methods based on various factors:

Cost:

In-House Document Review:

Conducting document review in-house involves using the law firm or organization’s own attorneys and support staff to review the documents. While this approach may have lower hourly rates for the reviewers, it often incurs higher overhead costs (office space, software, hardware, etc.) and potential inefficiencies due to the lack of specialized expertise.

Start my Document Review

Managed Document Review:

Managed document review involves outsourcing the review to a specialized third-party provider. These providers typically have the necessary technology, infrastructure, and experienced reviewers to handle large-scale reviews efficiently. The cost structure is more predictable and can be tailored to the specific needs of the case.

Scalability and Flexibility:

In-House Document Review:

The scalability of an in-house document review is limited to the firm’s available resources. If the case requires a sudden surge in document review capacity, it may be challenging to scale up quickly without compromising quality or incurring additional expenses.

Managed Document Review:

Managed document review providers can quickly scale their resources to meet the demands of large or time-sensitive projects. This flexibility allows for more efficient handling of high-volume document reviews without compromising quality.

Expertise and Technology:

In-House Document Review:

The expertise of in-house reviewers may be limited to the specific legal practice areas of the firm. Additionally, the firm may not have access to the latest document review technology, leading to potential inefficiencies and an increased risk of missing crucial information.

Managed Document Review:

Managed review providers often have a pool of experienced attorneys and subject matter experts from various legal domains. Moreover, they invest in cutting-edge technology, including advanced search algorithms and artificial intelligence tools, which can improve the accuracy and efficiency of the review process.

Data Security and Privacy:

In-House Document Review:

In-house document review may offer more direct control over data security and privacy since all aspects of the review process are handled internally. However, it also places the burden of maintaining robust security measures on the law firm or organization.

Managed Document Review:

Reputable managed review providers have strict data security and privacy protocols in place. They are experienced in handling sensitive information and have systems designed to protect client data from unauthorized access or breaches.

Project Management:

In-House Document Review:

Project management for in-house reviews is handled internally, which can be a challenging task if the firm lacks experience in managing large-scale document review projects.

Managed Document Review:

Managed review providers have dedicated project managers who are skilled at coordinating the review process, ensuring deadlines are met, and providing regular updates to the client.

Ultimately, the choice between in-house and managed document review depends on the specific needs of each case and the resources available to the law firm or organization. Small to mid-sized firms or those with limited resources may find that outsourcing the document review process to a specialized provider offers greater efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and access to expertise and technology. On the other hand, large firms with extensive resources and specialized practice areas may opt to conduct certain document reviews in-house to maintain control over the process.

Start my Document Review